Skip to main content
Spring Hill Christian Academy Schedule a tour

The case for classical Christian education

Is classical Christian education worth it? The pros and cons

Yes. A classical Christian education is worth it for a family that wants faith taught in every subject and knowledge put first. This page sets out the classical education pros and cons, makes the case for classical Christian education, and names what a family takes on.

Spring Hill Christian Academy is a classical Christian school in Spring Hill, Tennessee, for kindergarten through 8th grade. Our teaching follows the trivium: grammar, logic, and rhetoric, three stages of learning in that order.

Students in navy sweaters listening to their teacher at a classroom table

What are the benefits of classical education?

More families are choosing classical Christian schools, and the benefits show up in what your child does each day.

How much has classical Christian enrollment grown?

The National Center for Education Statistics counts private schools that report membership in the Association of Classical Christian Schools. Over 16 years, enrollment at those schools more than doubled, from 28,173 students to 60,210.

The starting figure comes from an earlier federal report on private schools. Over the same years, overall U.S. private school enrollment stayed about the same, near 5.1 million.

What SHCA students do in the grammar and logic stages

Children begin in the grammar stage, the early years of memory work. Memory work means learning a passage by heart, and it starts in kindergarten. Recitation is saying a memorized passage aloud.

Narration is telling back in your child’s own words what was just read. When your child narrates, the teacher hears what was understood.

Older students move to the logic stage, which covers 6th grade through 8th grade. There they ask how and why, take part in discussions the teacher leads with questions, and practice persuasive speaking. Every middle school student studies Latin.

History runs in order through time. Literature, geography, and the study of composers and artists follow the period being studied.

How faith runs through each subject at SHCA

Faith runs through each subject. Every course plan carries biblical integration objectives, and Bible is a course of its own. Science is taught as the study of what God made.

Every student attends chapel on Fridays at 9:00 a.m., and Scripture memory runs in every grade, with weekly class verses.

Scripture sets the pattern: “These commandments that I give you today are to be on your hearts. Impress them on your children. Talk about them when you sit at home and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up.” (Deuteronomy 6:6-7, NIV)

Why classical education builds knowledge first

A curriculum that builds knowledge first has support. In a study in the Journal of Educational Psychology, 64 junior high students read an account of a baseball game. Those who already knew about baseball recalled and understood more of it, strong readers and weak readers alike.

What your child already knows shapes what comes next, which is why classical education builds knowledge first. Our page on classical Christian education takes each stage further.

What are the criticisms of classical Christian education?

Parents tend to hear three criticisms of classical Christian education, and each one has an answer.

Does early memory work skip understanding?

The first criticism is memory work in the early grades. The worry is that children recall facts without understanding them.

Narration is our answer. In narration, your child retells a passage in fresh words, and the teacher hears what was understood.

A study in Psychological Science shows why recall practice is worth the effort. College-age students read a passage, then practiced recalling it or studied it again. A week later, the first group remembered 56 percent, and the second remembered 42 percent.

Is the classical workload too heavy for some children?

The second criticism is the load of reading, memory work, and writing, which parents hear can be too heavy for some children. At SHCA, homework is limited in the younger grades and scales as students age up and attention spans lengthen.

In 1st grade, homework averages about 20 minutes on a weeknight. In 2nd grade and 3rd grade that average is about 30 minutes, and in 4th grade through 8th grade it is about 45 minutes.

Each teacher sets the work, and classes average 15 students. Small classes are part of our mission, and they let a teacher notice when a child is struggling.

Are Latin and low technology old-fashioned?

The third criticism is Latin and SHCA’s light use of technology, which some parents find old-fashioned or impractical. Latin is close study of how a language is built, and every middle school student takes it. That work asks students to reason with what they learned earlier.

Phones are not used or seen during school hours, and they stay in the student’s backpack. Our reason: the foundations of learning, a child’s physical skills, and a developing brain come first, before technology and screens disrupt a student’s natural learning process.

SHCA’s phone-free choice has support. A study in Labour Economics looked at secondary schools in four English cities that banned phones.

Exam scores rose, and the largest gain went to the students who had been doing least well. A day without phones in hand keeps your child’s attention on the work of learning.

What does the research show?

The research is encouraging, though it has limits. A peer-reviewed study in the Journal of Research on Christian Education compared mean PSAT scores between classical Christian schools and other Christian schools.

The study drew on 4,486 mean scores on the PSAT, a national test, and the classical Christian schools scored higher in reading, math, and writing. The author noted limits: the families who choose each kind of school differ, and so do the schools.

Adults who attended schools in the Association of Classical Christian Schools answered a survey the association sponsored. Almost 55 percent said they earned A’s or mostly A’s in college, and nearly 90 percent attend church at least three times a month. Those answers are the alumni’s own report, given in the survey report.

What does it ask of a family?

Here is what we ask, so you can weigh the classical Christian education pros and cons for your family.

School meets on campus five days a week, from 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. Your family plans its week around a full school day.

Tuition is a real commitment for a family. You will find the figures on our tuition and fees page. Financial aid is based on need and covers part of tuition.

Families agree to our statement of faith at admission, and the family interview is your chance to ask deeper questions.

Students wear a uniform, under one dress code for every grade. Lunch comes from home, and a hot lunch is available on Fridays. Nightly homework in the higher grades and the phone rule are part of the regular week here.

Our school ends at 8th grade. The rhetoric stage is the third stage of the trivium, and it covers 9th grade through 12th grade. While high school is currently not available at SHCA, it is planned in our longer-term strategic vision.

Schedule a tour

Which families is it right for?

Is classical education better? It depends on fit. It is likely a good fit for families who:

  • Share the school’s statement of faith
  • Want the faith taught in every subject
  • Value reading, memory work, and discussion
  • Can commit to five full days, nightly homework in higher grades, the phone rule, and uniforms
  • Know that a high school decision comes after 8th grade

Some families will want a different kind of school. A family who wants a part-week program, or a school day with the faith left out, will not find that here.

Is it worth it for your family?

No study can settle what this school will mean for your child. For a family that wants faith taught in every subject and knowledge put first, the answer is yes. A member of staff leads a 45-minute visit, where you see the classrooms, walk the grounds, and meet our staff. Nothing about the visit commits you to applying.